Hand Scooped Milkshakes

"Top 10 Milkshakes in Pennsylvania" ~ Best Things in PA

"The 8 Very Best Milkshakes You Can Possibly Find in Pennsylvania" ~ Only In Your State

Create your own shake or ask to try a few of our Diner Girls’ favorite combos!

2 add-ins = 1,225 different combinations!

3 add-ins = 19,600 different combinations!

Shake It Up, Baby

  • REGULAR SHAKES • chocolate, strawberry, vanilla • 5.99
  • SHARE A SHAKE FOR AN EXTRA 1.00 • includes a second decorated glass with whipped cream & cherry
  • flavor Add-Ins • Amaretto, Apple Pie, Bacon, Banana, Blackberry, Blue Raspberry, Blueberry, Brownie, Butter Rum, Butterscotch, Cake Batter, Candied Pecans, Caramel, Cheesecake, Cherry, Chocolate Chips, Cinnamon, Coconut, Coffee, Confetti Sprinkles, English Toffee, Graham Cracker, Grape, Hot Fudge, Irish Cream, Lemon, Lime, M & M’s®, Malt Powder, Maple Syrup, Marshmallow Fluff, Nilla Wafers®, Nutella, Orange, Oreo®, Pancake Batter, Peach, Peanut Butter, Peanuts, Peppermint, Pineapple, Pistachio, Red Raspberry, Red Velvet Cake, Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup®, Reese’s Pieces®
    Salted Caramel, Sugar Cookie, Tiramisu, Watermelon • 1.00 each
  • MALT-ese FALCON • old fashioned ice cream malts • 6.99
  • LITTLE SUSIE • 12 oz. root beer float • 2.99

My Favorite Things

  • BANANA CREAM PIE • vanilla with banana and graham cracker or nilla wafer
  • BREAKFAST SHAKE • vanilla with bacon and maple syrup OR pancake batter and maple syrup
  • BIRTHDAY BASH • Birthday cake batter and confetti sprinkles
  • PB&J • vanilla with peanut butter and grape
  • PEANUT BUTTER/BANANA • vanilla or chocolate with banana and peanut butter
  • PINA COLADA • vanilla with coconut and pineapple
  • RED VELVET • vanilla with red velvet cake mix and cheesecake
  • S’MORE • chocolate with marshmallow and graham cracker
  • TURTLE (WHITE OR DARK) • vanilla or chocolate with chocolate syrup, caramel and pecans

Featured Milkshakes

Check out this month’s specialty milkshakes, available for a limited time! • 6.99

Donna's Diner Waitress
Hand-Scooped Milkshakes at Donna's Diner in Sharon, PA